Bastardo

Article and
Tasting Notes by
George Heritier



 

  |

2007 Luca Malbec MendozaWe have a tongue-in-cheek descriptor for a certain style of wine here at Gang Central, that being “breakfast wine.” We call them that because they show definite flavors and aromas reminiscent of coffee and toast, no doubt from the specific char put on the oak barrels used to ferment and age the wines. These traits seem to be especially prominent in wines from Argentina and Chile, and we’ve had the opportunity to try a number of them lately. Now, we’re not really suggesting that you drink these wines with or for breakfast, but we suppose you can if you want! Please note that there are some whites included in our report, because after all, they were included in the samples we received, and it only seems right to do so.

We started out with two wines from Laura Catena’s Argentine side project, Luca (named after her oldest son). The project focuses on her vision of producing "a new breed of Argentine wines," with "small quantities, artisan quality and true to their individual terroirs." The model is to purchase grapes from small family owned vineyards, some of the oldest and most unique in Mendoza.

2007 Luca Malbec Mendoza, 14.5% alc., $35: Deep, dark, inky color, with notes of coffee, toffee and chocolate setting the tone for the aromatics. These follow through on the palate over a big core of black currant, blackberry and blueberry, full bodied with a svelte, smooth texture that coexists with its solid structure. I can drink this and see why it has fans and garners big scores, but it’s not a style that I favor and I would never buy it. Air does help it, however, bringing out more of the coffee and some earth while toning down the toffee and chocolate, giving more of the gaucho Malbec character that I’ve come to expect from these. It might be interesting to see what 3 to 5 years in the cellar do for this.
Find this wine

2006 Luca Chardonnay Altos de Mendoza, 13.9% alc., $30: Medium straw, bordering on pale gold in color, with ripe pear, pineapple and sweet pea flavors and aromas; not terribly complex, but not excessively oaked either. Full bodied, with good weight, balanced acids and good length, making for a solid, if overpriced Chardonnay. I can’t help but shake my head at one well-placed critic who characterized this as “… blows away most white Burgundies and California Chardonnays at twice the price.” Find this wine

Imported by Vine Connections, Sausalito, CA

~~~~~~~~

We've had mixed impressions of Vineyards Brands' Chilean Cono Sur project; they do nice things with most of their whites and some of their reds, but some of the latter are mucked up with too much oak. We like the wines of VB’s Argentine project Dona Paula pretty much across the board, however, as they show much more consistency.

2007 Dona Paula Lujan de Cuyo Estate Chardonnay, 13.5% alc., $16: Pale to medium straw in color, with straightforward, somewhat steely Chardonnay flavors and aromas of apple, pear and a hint of canned peas. Full bodied, with balanced acidity and good length; serviceable and well made. Find this wine

2007 Dona Paula Lujan de Cuyo Estate Malbec, 14% alc., $16: Deep, dark color, with coffee and toast in good proportion to the black currant and cocoa flavors and aromas; the toast and coffee becomes more accentuated as it opens with air, dominating but not overwhelming the character of the wine. This can use a good five years in the cellar, but that’s not to say it’s not already quite approachable. Not my favorite style of red wine, but undeniably well made. Find this wine

Dona Paula Tupungato Estate Merlot 2006, 14% alc., $16: Rich dark color; coffee, smoke and toast accent the rich red and black berry and currant core of fruit. With good weight, concentration and structure, this is drinking well now, with the potential to age and improve for two, three or maybe even five years. Just enough toast and coffee; any more and I probably wouldn’t care for this. A nice Merlot at a fair price that likes a little air. Find this wine

2007 Dona Paula Cabernet Sauvignon2007 Dona Paula Lujan de Cuyo Estate Cabernet Sauvignon, 14% alc., $16: Inky color, fading to purple-pink at the rim; sea air and cedar on the nose, with more of the same along with black currant, mocha and soft leather on the palate. Smooth and harmonious, yet deceptively well structured for three to five years of development and improvement. The cedar, leather and mocha set the tone for the character of this nice wine. Find this wine

2006 Dona Paula Lujan de Cuyo Estate Shiraz-Malbec, 14% alc., $16: Good dark color, with what is by now the requisite toast and coffee character, though not as dominant as with many of the others noted here. Full bodied, with a rich core of dark plum and berry, with smooth texture and good structure and length. A solid red blend that performs more than just yeoman's duty with a variety of grilled red meats. Find this wine

2007 Dona Paula Los Cardos Lujan de Cuyo Sauvignon Blanc, 13% alc., $10: Medium straw color, with boxwood, grapefruit and gooseberry on the nose, which echo and expand on the palate; decent depth and intensity, with good acidity. A good everyday Sauvignon and a nice match for whole wheat spaghetti with Swiss chard, lentils, lemon juice and olive oil. Find this wine

2007 Dona Paula Los Cardos Lujan de Cuyo Chardonnay, 13.5% alc., $10: Pale gold color, with sweet pea and pear flavors and aromas shaded with a hint of citrus-lime, well integrated oak and a steely undertone; not delicate by any means, but shows a certain refined character that belies its price tag. The wine’s personality seems to be an extension of the color, as it tastes golden. Full bodied, but not at all heavy, with good acids, depth and length; all in all, a pretty Chardonnay. Find this wine

2007 Dona Paula Los Cardos Tupungato Merlot, 14% alc., $10: Deep, dark color, fading to purple-pink at the rim; moderate char-toast over decent red and black currant and berry. Fairly rich and round, with oak that plays its role without killing the wine. Good depth and structure, and while it doesn’t quite have the impact of the following wine, it does what it’s supposed to. The cynic in me wants to say not bad for Merlot, and the kinder, gentler guy says pretty much the same thing. Find this wine

2007 Dona Paula Los Cardos Lujan de Cuyo Malbec2007 Dona Paula Los Cardos Lujan de Cuyo Malbec, 14% alc., $10: Youthful dark garnet color, fading to purple-pink at the rim; spice, spice and candied red berries on the nose and on the palate, with subtle hints of coffee and toast; any more of the latter two qualities and I might not care for it, but as is, it’s nice. With good, weight and balance, this is structured for at least a few years of development and maybe a few more to hold after that. Fairly rich and ripe, with some oak, but nothing excessive. Good QPR here. Find this wine

2007 Dona Paula Los Cardos Lujan de Cuyo Cabernet Sauvignon, 14% alc., $10: Deep, dark color, with ripe, round fruit, more red than black; soft cocoa, balsa and leather shades the red currant, plum and berry flavors and aromas. Good weight, structure and length, and if it’s not all that typical of the variety (nothing about it screams “Cabernet” to me), it’s easy to enjoy and pairs nicely with grilled organic beef hamburgers with Dijon mustard and horseradish. Find this wine

2006 Dona Paula Los Cardos Lujan de Cuyo Syrah, 13.5% alc., $10: Deep purple garnet color, fading to pink at the rim; nice, rich dark plum and mulberry flavors and aromas are graced with restrained toasty oak and coffee. Full bodied, well structured and earthy at its core, and it all comes together nicely on the palate. Good now, with at least two to three years of aging potential. Find this wine

Imported by Vineyards Brands, Inc., Birmingham. AL
~~~~~~~~

Our friend Jerome Smith, of Select Fine Wine, wanted our opinion on some of that company’s Argentine and Chilean selections, so we tried them and found all four to offer solid QPR.

2007 Molto! Malbec Mendoza2007 Molto! Malbec Mendoza, 14.5% alc., $9.99: Deep dark color, with a nose full of mocha, coffee and toast, and plenty more of the same in the full bodied flavors. Fairly smooth, yet well structured, and if it isn’t terribly complex, it shows good intensity and is nice for what it is. Very good QPR. Find this wine

2005 Odfjell Armador Merlot Valle del Maipo, 14% alc., $11.99: Clean dark color, with red currant and red berry aromatics that follow through on the palate with some coffee, toast and earthy undertones in support; medium full to full bodied with good depth and structure, not quite chewy, but certainly substantial. Good merlot and then some; not too complex, but what’s here is enjoyable. Find this wine

2005 Odfjell Armador Cabernet Sauvignon Valle del Maipo2005 Odfjell Armador Cabernet Sauvignon Valle del Maipo, 14% alc., $11.99: Shows good dark color, with a restrained coffee, toasty char and black fruit nose that leads into fairly ripe, not quite candied red and black currant flavors shaded with some coffee. Has enough guts and structure to stand up to a good grilled steak and enough ripe fruit to serve to your “the only wine is red wine” friends as a starter. Find this wine

2005 Odfjell Armador Carmenere Muale/Maipo, 13.5% alc., $11.99: Good dark color, with coffee, currants and a little petroleum on the nose; the coffee and earthy black currant flavors are rich and ripe, but not too ripe. Medium to medium full bodied, with good structure, intensity and length, and like the other two Armadors, while it’s not real complex, what’s here is nice and it’s a good choice to enjoy a glass with burgers, pizza or even flank steak. Find this wine

Imported by Select Fine Wine, Manhasset, NY

Reporting from Day-twah,

geo t.

Other Recent Wine Explorations

A Hattrick in Triple Overtime Redux:
Recent Wines from Igor Larionov

Samples Up the Waz!

Fall Fest~The Cleve~2008

It's All Good!

A Southern Rhone Wine Dinner

Finding Hidden Bench

8 from Cono Sur

10 from Arcadian

Back to the December 2008 Index

Back to the Underground Index

Back to the Top


© George Heritier December, 2008